School security specifications aren’t changing, despite concerns

  • 11 Jul 2018

Jacksons Fencing, the leading perimeter security manufacturer in the UK, reveals architects’ insights on school safety in its report ‘Protecting the Future’. The report highlights substantial differences in views between architects and school management as well as outlining the common ground. It incorporates teachers’ perspectives on security matters.

– Schools have weak points in their perimeters and entrances, say one third of architects

– Multiple entry points are the greatest access control challenge affecting schools (90%)

– Three-quarters of school refurbishment specifications remain unchanged from the original ones (71%)

– Only 47% of architects know about LPS 1175

Almost two-thirds of architects know of schools being affected by problems with fencing and gates (60%). This is reflected in head teachers’ greatest concerns, unauthorised exits and entrances (30% and 25%). Most head teachers have commissioned new access solutions at least once (63%) and over three-quarters have had their perimeter inspected within the past five years (80%).

However, the majority of architects (71%) find that school security refurbishments use the original specifications with some value-engineering implying that these known these problems are clearly not being resolved.

Specification evasion

There are major concerns over cost and disruption, which are reflected in the number of schools keeping the same specifications despite security issues. Architects identify ‘budget’ as the greatest challenge when installing school fencing (84%), followed by restricted installation times (48%) and working where children are present (39%).

However, a perimeter’s cost is not the leading issue for school security. For teachers, performance is the highest priority (73%), followed closely by security ratings and accredited products (68%). These come ahead of lifetime (64%) and initial costs (59%).

Setting standards

Head teachers say that creating a positive learning environment (86%) and keeping the school community safe (82%) are the most important duties of their job. The role that school staff play in ensuring the safety of pupils has been reinforced by recent bomb threats sent to schools in the UK. One way of achieving protection is to ensure their security solutions meet industry standards.

A third of architects are seeing Secured by Design (SBD) and LPS 1175 standards increasingly specified (31%). A significant 95% are familiar with SBD. However, there are still improvements to be made: currently, under half of architects know about LPS 1175 (47%).

Head teachers may be concerned about the safety of their pupils, but it’s revealed that 39% don’t know where to go to find out more about school security and access control. They do, however, have some awareness of safety guidelines: half of school teachers, for example, are familiar with the recommended height for school fences. A similar portion know of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA) guidelines, which mainly apply to playgrounds.

The inside perspective

Overall, architects’ views on school security are in line with teachers: 32% and 29% respectively acknowledge weak points in the perimeter. There is also agreement between both parties about which safety issues are afflicting schools the most: multiple entrances, having difficult to see areas and more than one building.

The report does show, however, that architects are more acutely aware of these problems than teachers: there is a 40% average difference between their responses to more probing questions. This disparity was especially marked where 72% of architects said that aging fencing is an issue, compared to 16% of teachers.

Cris Francis, Security Consultant at Jacksons Fencing, comments: “While there is a healthy level of agreement between architects and teachers on what the key school security issues are, our research reveals some concerning differences. Despite schools prioritising the performance of their fencing and gates, architects are up against stringent budgets that lead to maintaining outdated solutions or down specifying. Schools need to find a way of balancing cost with adequately ensuring children’s safety. Part of the problem might be that without a professional understanding of design and security, school staff can’t appreciate the impact of perimeter issues to the same extent as architects.

“Architects also have a greater awareness of safety standards and LPS 1175 certified products. By using their expertise to help schools choose the most appropriate solution for their specific risks and needs, they can help safeguard staff and students alike from future harm.”

Leave a Reply

More articles

Bull Products

Bull sails forward with Norwegian shipyard contract

Bull Products has strengthened its presence in the shipbuilding industry, after securing a partnership with a major Norwegian distributor.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Building Systems, Case Studies, Facility Management & Building Services, Health & Safety, Posts, Security and Fire Protection, Site Preparation


BMI UK & Ireland launches to the UK construction industry

Following the coming together of Icopal and Monier Redland, and a period of investment in premises, systems and people, BMI UK & Ireland has been formally launched to the construction industry.

Posted in Articles, Building Associations & Institutes, Building Industry Events, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Building Systems, news, Posts, Restoration & Refurbishment, Retrofit & Renovation, Roof Edge Protection, Roofs


Troldtekt explores the rise of darker colours in its latest theme

With heavier materials and darker colours being used in more and more projects, Troldtekt is exploring the movement in detail in its latest Theme.

Posted in Acoustics, Noise & Vibration Control, Articles, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Ceilings, Innovations & New Products, Interiors, Paints, Coatings & Finishes, Posts