SuDS policy fudge must be avoided to prevent flood chaos

  • 5 Nov 2014

Alex Stephenson, chair of the British Water Surface Water Management Focus Group

Alex Stephenson, chair of the British Water Surface Water Management Focus Group and Group Market Development Director of Hydro International said:

The speed and scale of changes have come as a surprise to many, caused confusion and raised many unanswered questions. The result could be a free-for-all for SuDS. Despite the Governments intentions, the outcome could well be a fudge and a post code lottery that sees fewer schemes built to SuDS principles with no robust way of ensuring they will be maintained or work as designed.

To mitigate this, a strong lead will be essential to ensure sensible and practical national guidance that lays out a full toolbox of both natural and manufactured SuDS components, with clear, repeatable maintenance schedules. The revised CIRIA SuDS manual will be a critical part of this and must reflect a pragmatic approach to a national framework for best practice.

SuDS hindering recovery

The new system addresses developer concerns that compulsory SuDS might hamper the building recovery by increasing development time, construction and land-opportunity costs, and that all Local Authorities were not fully ready to take up the SAB mantle and more importantly, maintain and adopt the SuDS.

Instead the existing planning system will be strengthened to incorporate an expectation for SuDS on new developments of 10 properties or more, according to National Standards. The consultation also sets out a requirement for developers (rather than the Local Authority as previously proposed) to demonstrate how SuDS components will be effectively maintained.

However, in practice, its hard to be confident that the proposals will truly encourage a greater uptake of SuDS on the scale originally intended and will deal sufficiently with environmental water quality.

In particular, the proposals may give too much leeway for planners to exempt the use of SuDS if the developer argues successfully that they are too costly to build or maintain. They may also be subject to widely-differing local policies.

The developments could jeopardise effective flood control and water quality

Monitoring SuDS components

I am also extremely concerned that there is no clear indication of how SuDS components will be monitored to check they are built properly and perform as designed throughout their life. Theres no suggestion so far that they will be inspected by Building Control or another body to check they are built and continue to be effective.

Manufactured products come with a predictable and repeatable maintenance schedule, but its much harder to predict how natural features will continue to perform and all components need to be maintained properly. We have already seen examples of SuDS being left orphaned or neglected both in both Scotland and England and a so-called flexible and permissive approach to maintenance in practice could end up seeing SuDS that simply do not provide the flood control and treatment required.

To be effective, these proposals must reflect a truly pragmatic and sensible approach to meeting source control and water quality objectives using the entire SuDS toolbox and both natural and manufactured components.

A Government consultation on the proposals closed on 24 October.



Leave a Reply

Latest news


Better Data, Safer Building: CPA launches consultation on new Product Information Code

The Construction Products Association (CPA) is launching an industry-wide consultation into a new proposed Code for Construction Product Information (CCPI).

Posted in Articles, Building Associations & Institutes, Building Industry News, Building Regulations & Accreditations, Health & Safety, Information Technology, Innovations & New Products, news, Publications


Builders’ Merchants’ sales grow 9% despite second lockdown - BMBI

The latest Builders Merchants Building Index (BMBI) report confirms that value sales to builders and contractors by Britain’s builders’ merchants in November 2020 saw its largest year-on-year increase since March 2019

Posted in Articles, Building Associations & Institutes, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Building Systems, Civil Engineering, Facility Management & Building Services, Landscaping, news, Research & Materials Testing, Timber Buildings and Timber Products


Vytaliving launches 15 minute COVID tests to keep your workplace functional and safe

Vytaliving brings to the market a comprehensively tested and certified personal 15-minute rapid COVID testing kit, for antigens and antibodies.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Facility Management & Building Services, Health & Safety, Innovations & New Products, news, Research & Materials Testing, Site Preparation

Contour Heating

Young Offender Institutions: The Design Considerations with Contour

This piece from Contour explores the design considerations for young offender institutions, in order to allow for the best possible chance of rehabilitation and for officers to manage behaviours effectively.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Building Services, Health & Safety, Heating Systems, Controls and Management, Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning - HVAC, Interiors, Retrofit & Renovation