Martin Townsend

House of Lords is right to emphasise housebuilding quality over focus on speed and volume

  • 23 Feb 2016

Martin Townsend, Director of Sustainability at BRE Global, discusses the House of Lords report on improving the quality and health of homes.

Published last week, the House of Lords Select Committee report Building Better Places makes significant and welcome recommendations to improve the quality and health of homes being constructed in the future rather than merely focusing on delivery. But will they be taken seriously by Government which has committed itself to building 400,000 homes by 2020?

The report raises important concerns that an emphasis on speed and volume in order to deliver the numbers is likely to be at the expense of considerations of place-making and wider sustainability of developments. They also stress that local authorities with reduced financial freedom are less likely to be able to play the full part in contributing to new housebuilding which they need to in order to achieve the goals.

Poor housing has a major impact on health and therefore cost to the nation. The Lords quote the BRE study in their report which estimated that the total health cost to the NHS is in the region of £1.4bn to £2bn for England alone. This shows the scale of the problem, it is not just about creating buildings which have kerb appeal.

The UK Industry Performance Report published last year by Glenigan found that customer satisfaction with housing projects had dropped from an 88% maximum between 2003 and 2012 to 74% in 2015. While this drop could be partly explained by the fact that efforts by the BRE and other organisations to drive housebuilding quality has led to greater consumer engagement with and expectations of quality, but the size of the drop also suggests that there is a problem currently in delivering it across the board.

The House of Lords report is huge and wide-ranging, and along the way makes some strongly-worded criticisms and some very important recommendations. Some of these may well see the light of day given the high-profile and prestigious nature of those who have delivered it. The focus is on rebuilding the central role of Government in being both the catalyst and custodian of design quality in the industry.

The main outcome is the recommendation of a Chief Built Environment Adviser who would be able to integrate policy across Government departments. This would help to resolve what the Lords say is a damaging fragmentation of that policy currently. This appointment would be underpinned and bolstered by a review of the Government’s Construction Strategy which would give the Government a far greater leadership role in creating and implementing standards of design quality, including restoring some of the powers it lost when the Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment was dissolved.

Perhaps less likely to be realised are the report’s calls for a reversal of the removal of the zero carbon homes target, and the Code for Sustainable Homes. However the cogently worded call for the Government to “implement a viable trajectory towards energy efficiency and carbon reduction in new homes” is something many across the industry would strongly support. Also the recommendation for Governments and local authorities to encourage development on smaller sites will receive a lot of warm approval not least from SME builders.

We echo the concerns of the report’s authors that the current focus on delivering volume in housebuilding is risking a negative effect on quality. While delivering volume is crucial, in the current climate of deregulation in the planning system combined with intensification of housebuilding there are clear risks, however the report contains some clear ways forward to prevent detrimental results. We cannot help but agree that the UK needs to fully recognise the “power of place” as the report’s authors put it, and be more ambitious in creating high quality housing, to avoid increased longer term cost but also enhance well-being of occupants and communities in the short-term.

As part of delivering this, we support the idea of a stable National Planning Policy Framework to offer consumers and businesses the certainty they need. However we agree with the Lords that more investment is needed in planning departments’ capacity and skills to proactively drive design quality and achieve sustainable high quality housebuilding.

We highlighted a disconnect between housebuilders and homeowners on long-term quality highlighted when we gave evidence to a Government Inquiry into the Quality of New Build Housing in England held in October 2015. Use of wide-ranging independent standards that are demonstrably robust and which combine the interests of homeowners with the construction industry are a solution.

Leave a Reply

Latest news

Mitsubshi Electric

Family Day Workshop by Mitsubishi Electric

If you are an architecture or environmental enthusiast, bring your children along to a family day of fun and educational activities at the Building Centre on Saturday 22nd June – Mitsubishi Electric will deliver its award-winning programme, The Learning Curve (with a few twists), designed to teach children about energy use and energy efficiency.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry Events, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Facility Management & Building Services, Heating Systems, Controls and Management, Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning - HVAC, Pipes & Fittings, Plumbing, Retrofit & Renovation, Sustainability & Energy Efficiency


Keller Kitchens excels in Kiwa assessment

Keller Kitchens has been reassessed by Kiwa, a European institute that is involved in the certification of processes, products, employees and organisations. Once again, the company passed with flying colours!

Posted in Articles, Building Associations & Institutes, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Regulations & Accreditations, Building Services, Interior Design & Construction, Interiors, Kitchens, Research & Materials Testing, Restoration & Refurbishment, Retrofit & Renovation, Sustainability & Energy Efficiency

National Ventilation

National Ventilation’s Operations Director Completes D-Day 44 Challenge

Alan Parkinson, Operations Director at National Ventilation, has completed the D-Day 44 Challenge in aid of Combat Stress, the UK’s leading charity for veterans’ mental health.

Posted in Air Conditioning, Articles, Building Industry Events, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Charity work, Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning - HVAC