Bankrupt hospitals and emergency closure of 17 PFI built schools

  • 11 Apr 2016

howardchapmanHoward Chapman, Buildingtalk Editor, asks if the next big scandal will be about the dodgy PFI deals that are bankrupting public services.

While the NHS struggles with PFI debt, some children will not return to school today as 17 PFI-built schools in Scotland stay closed for safety checks. Will this force all past PFI deals onto the front page?

The Guardian reports today that the closure PFI-built facilities over safety concerns will mean thousands of pupils in Scotland cannot go back to school today after their Easter break. Councils are checking their school buildings as fears grow that all schools built under the same private finance initiative could pose a safety risk to children and staff – watch the latest BBC video on inspections are being carried out at all the Edinburgh PPI-built schools.

Some say that private financing of schools, hospitals, infrastructure and other core public services is not sustainable because many of the deals struck were such poor value. PFI was devised by the Tories in the 90’s and championed by Gordon Brown in the Labour years. They are a key factor in the ‘bankrupting’ of some NHS Trusts, the debt burden preventing more than 20 having any chance of balancing their books.

UK taxpayers now owe over £300 billion in PFI repayments across 700+ projects for the next 30 years. These crippling lease arrangements for PFI projects mean young people starting work now will pay taxes for PFI until they are nearly 70. Some private contractors who agreed PFI deals are set to make billions of pounds in profit, with some due to see returns of up to 70%.

Some say only an act of parliament can force a reversal of some of the dodgy deals that are such poor value to the public sector and now seem like a licence for the private sector to print money. But can this really happen?

Should there be a real investigation to find out what went wrong and who made a killing? Where do you stand on the PFI value for money scandal?

2 comments on “Bankrupt hospitals and emergency closure of 17 PFI built schools

  • These PFI arrangements were an opportunity for a small section of society to milk the NHS and the local Authority public purse. The deals were at best ‘Dodgy’ and at worst Criminal.
    Those who profited from them and those who arranged them should be brought to book and their profits and assets confiscated in recompense.
    There needs to be a reversal of the contracts as they are obviously dishonest and immoral.

  • UPDATE: Edinburgh council has confirmed that building defects and flaws have been uncovered in all 17 schools closed for safety reasons, as fears grow that some may not reopen until the autumn.
    Andrews Burns, the city’s council leader, said some of the buildings could be closed in the longer term but said money spent on rehousing the 7,600 children affected was already being “clawed back” from the private finance firm that built the schools.
    Read more via The Guardian

Leave a Reply

Latest news

Newton Waterproofing

The Newton Waterproofing App – Now on Desktop!

The free Newton Waterproofing App has undergone a major update, including moving to a Google software development kit and adding a host of new features.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Damp & Waterproofing, Facility Management & Building Services, Information Technology, Innovations & New Products

BBI Services

BBI Services: The problem with plan-do-review

Marc Roberts, Chief Operations Officer at BBI Services, tackles the topic of how to implement workable strategies for improving productivity and efficiency.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Building Services, Facility Management & Building Services, Site Preparation


Recofloor 2022 Awards Event kicks off in April

Recofloor’s 2022 rugby-themed awards event – the first in-person occasion for three years – kicks off in April at the renowned Twickenham Stadium.

Posted in Articles, Awards, Building Industry Events, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Exhibitions and Conferences, Facility Management & Building Services, Floors, Site Preparation, Sustainability & Energy Efficiency, Waste Management & Recycling


DCW 2021: Picture and video highlights of last year's show

Digital Construction Week was delighted to finally have the chance to welcome thousands of visitors to the show once again, between 24 – 25 November 2021.

Posted in Articles, BIM, Infrastructure & CAD Software, Building Industry Events, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Exhibitions and Conferences, Information Technology, Innovations & New Products, Seminars, Video of the Week