Builders risk cashflow problems & higher tax as HMRC clamps down on accounting errors

  • 19 Sep 2014

Whatever the truth of the matter, HMRC is becoming increasingly rigorous in ensuring compliance in the construction industry and is penalising a growing number of small builders for often quite minor mistakes.

According to data we obtained under the Freedom of Information Act, a growing proportion of builders are at risk of cashflow problems and paying more tax as HMRC clamps down on tax and accounting errors. The official figures show that in the most recent tax year 2,318 subcontractors in the construction industry had their Gross Payment Status – their right to be paid without deductions made for tax – revoked by HMRC. This is the highest number in three years.

Subcontractors who are paid gross are subject to an annual compliance check. Over a quarter (28 per cent) of subcontractors who failed their annual compliance check lost their Gross Payment Status, up from 22 per cent in 2012/13.

The loss of Gross Payment Status can be severely damaging for builders, potentially resulting in higher tax, reduced cashflow, breach of contract with contractors and reduced opportunities to tender for work.

Subcontractors can apply for Gross Payment Status under the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) administered by HMRC. The advantages for subcontractors of being registered for Gross Payment Status include reduced National Insurance contributions and the ability to offset legitimate business-related expenses against their tax liability at the end of each tax year.

While HMRC is becoming less forgiving of minor mistakes, such as filing a return a few days late or owing a relatively small amount of tax, the good news is that, in most cases, these mistakes are easy to rectify. Being fully compliant is quite straightforward, and given the damage losing Gross Payment Status can have on a business, it is worth spending a bit of time to ensure that the taxman is satisfied. At SJD Accountancy, we tell our clients to bear the following in mind:

• Keep on top of deadlines and ensure that returns and taxes are filed and paid on time.

• If you are facing difficulty paying tax, have a conversation with HMRC, who may be sympathetic if it is due to a late payment elsewhere in the supply chain. Far better to discuss with HMRC than simply pay tax late without any explanation.
• Put money aside each month to cover tax. It is good practice to have a separate bank account for tax and as a rule of thumb to set aside 25 per cent of each month’s income for tax. Income over £41,866 will be taxed at 40%, which means you will need to set aside more.

• The same goes for VAT. Transfer the VAT portion of your monthly income to the separate bank account as well, so that you have sufficient funds to cover quarterly VAT payments.

• SJD clients are advised to keep all their receipts. Legitimate business expenses can be offset against your tax bill, and the VAT element can be reclaimed/deducted from your VAT bill. HMRC does not always check, but if they do and your records are inadequate, you may be deemed not fully compliant.  

Subcontractors who lose their gross payment status for relatively minor mistakes can appeal the decision, but they will need to convince HMRC that the issue was an isolated error, which can be a time-consuming and costly process. Losing Gross Payment Status can be very damaging, but easily avoided. Keeping on top of your taxes can be a challenge on top of the day to day running of your business, which is why it is always advisable to seek professional advice if in doubt.

Leave a Reply

Latest news


Better Data, Safer Building: CPA launches consultation on new Product Information Code

The Construction Products Association (CPA) is launching an industry-wide consultation into a new proposed Code for Construction Product Information (CCPI).

Posted in Articles, Building Associations & Institutes, Building Industry News, Building Regulations & Accreditations, Health & Safety, Information Technology, Innovations & New Products, news, Publications


Builders’ Merchants’ sales grow 9% despite second lockdown - BMBI

The latest Builders Merchants Building Index (BMBI) report confirms that value sales to builders and contractors by Britain’s builders’ merchants in November 2020 saw its largest year-on-year increase since March 2019

Posted in Articles, Building Associations & Institutes, Building Industry News, Building Products & Structures, Building Services, Building Systems, Civil Engineering, Facility Management & Building Services, Landscaping, news, Research & Materials Testing, Timber Buildings and Timber Products


Vytaliving launches 15 minute COVID tests to keep your workplace functional and safe

Vytaliving brings to the market a comprehensively tested and certified personal 15-minute rapid COVID testing kit, for antigens and antibodies.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Facility Management & Building Services, Health & Safety, Innovations & New Products, news, Research & Materials Testing, Site Preparation

Contour Heating

Young Offender Institutions: The Design Considerations with Contour

This piece from Contour explores the design considerations for young offender institutions, in order to allow for the best possible chance of rehabilitation and for officers to manage behaviours effectively.

Posted in Articles, Building Industry News, Building Services, Health & Safety, Heating Systems, Controls and Management, Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning - HVAC, Interiors, Retrofit & Renovation